Cheers for Animal Charity Evaluators

Animal Charity Evaluators (ACE) released a long-overdue report on protest effectiveness. I'm biased because I'm quoted there, but I thought I would take the occasion to note how much I think ACE has grown in the past few years. I'm tremendously grateful to ACE's founders, but when ACE started out (as "Effective Animal Advocacy"), its advice was rudimentary, based on little science, and made by a very small staff. I'm struck by the careful and nuanced conclusion the report reaches:

Overall, we would like to see the animal advocacy movement invest slightly more heavily in protests. Protests currently receive a tiny portion of the movement’s resources and, given the limited evidence we do have, it’s plausible they are at least as cost-effective as interventions that receive much more of the movement’s resources, such as leafleting. Moreover, we think that the use of protests contributes to the diversity of tactics in the movement, which can help attract a greater number and variety of activists to the cause and thereby increase our chances of success.

Now the organization is fully professional, has a research agenda including a division dedicated to original research such as randomized evaluations, and has a careful and sensitive review process. While I think they may still have a bias toward measurability, I think their charity recommendations are defensible, and they are aware of this bias. They do avoid other common EA biases, like dismissing confrontation or "emotional" activism out of hand or running headstrong into radical conclusions (e.g. there is net suffering in the wild) without tempering those conclusions a bit.


A year ago, Harrison Nathan posted an article on Medium criticizing much of ACE's decision-making. I agreed with most of his points. I also see the whole episode as an utterly tragic affair, as I saw all parties (who I deeply respect) pick a side, stoop to ad hominem arguments, and dismiss the other's points.

I know Harrison disagrees with me, but I think most of his blog is still compatible with supporting ACE as an institution. I support ACE because I think that (a) its mission and symbolism as an organization promoting scientific, consequentialist thinking is itself valuable; (b) its charity evaluations and views at least set out a number of useful basic principles most (not all) advocates should follow: to focus on farmed animals and to think about impact and measurement; and (c) its charity evaluations, as flawed as they are, are pretty good given the state of evidence on animal advocacy.

More cause for optimism, though, is that ACE is regularly improving. I fully believe in the staff and am excited to see where ACE goes next.

Comments

  1. This nice post. It is really good website. thanks for share this information. many companies offer pure dog balance food reviews and other animals medicines. they cant give y ou this type of information for selling. many thnaks.

    ReplyDelete
  2. This is an awesome post.Really very informative and creative contents. These concept is a good way to enhance the knowledge.I like it and help me to development very well.Thank you for this brief explanation and very nice information.Well, got a good knowledge.
    Digital Marketing Course in Chennai
    Digital Marketing Training in Chennai
    Java Training in Chennai
    Web Designing Course in chennai
    PHP Training in Chennai
    Hadoop Training in Chennai
    Digital Marketing Training in Tnagar

    ReplyDelete

  3. You write this post very carefully I think, which is easily understandable to me. Not only this, but another post is also good. As a newbie, this info is really helpful for me. Thanks to you.
    Tally ERP 9 Training
    tally classes
    Tally Training institute in Chennai
    Tally course in Chennai

    ReplyDelete
  4. Great Article. Thank you for sharing! Really an awesome post for every one.
    Digital Marketing Course In Kolkata

    ReplyDelete
  5. It's very useful article with inforamtive and insightful content and i had good experience with this information.Enroll today to get free access to our live demo session which is a great opportunity to interact with the trainer directly which is a placement based Salesforce training India with job placement and certification . I strongly recommend my friends to join this Salesforce training institutes in hyderabad practical course, great curriculum Salesforce training institutes in Bangalore with real time experienced faculty Salesforce training institutes in Chennai. Never delay to enroll for a free demo at Salesforce training institutes in Mumbai who are popular for Salesforce training institutes in Pune.

    ReplyDelete
  6. You write this post very carefully I think, which is easily understandable to me. Not only this, but another post is also good .keep updating lots of details.
    AngularJS training in chennai | AngularJS training in anna nagar | AngularJS training in omr | AngularJS training in porur | AngularJS training in tambaram | AngularJS training in velachery

    ReplyDelete
  7. Myself so glad to establish your blog entry since it's actually quite instructive. If it's not too much trouble continue composing this sort of web journal and I normally visit this blog. Examine my administrations.
    Go through these Salesforce Lightning Features course. Found this Salesforce CRM Using Apex And Visualforce Training worth joining. Enroll for SalesForce CRM Integration Training Program and practice well. 

    ReplyDelete
  8. I am so happy to found your blog post because it's really very informative. Please keep writing this kind of blogs and I regularly visit this blog. Have a look at my services.  
    This is really the best Top 20 Salesforce CRM Admin Development Interview Questions highly helpful. I have found these Scenario based Salesforce developers interview questions and answers very helpful to attempt job interviews. Wow, i got this scenario based Salesforce interview questions highly helpful.    

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

What I Learned from a Year Spent Studying How to Get Policymakers to Use Evidence

How Much Do Wild Animals Suffer? A Foundational Result on the Question is Wrong.

A Funny Thing Happened While Selling Cory Booker to Vegans