A Funny Thing Happened While Selling Cory Booker to Vegans
Last Friday I wrote a post in support of Cory Booker's presidency. The main audience was animal advocates, though I also aimed it at the general public and wrote about a number of his policies and politics that I think recommend him.
My original version of the post included a section that I decided to delete. In the deleted section, I predicted that a lot of people concerned with animals would immediately dismiss the first true animal advocate running for president based on other stances, something they would never do for human issues. It's striking to me how accurate my predictions are, so I thought it was worth sharing what I removed from the post, which I think underlines a problem not only among vegans but also on the left in general: that there is a socially-enforced ranking of issues that nearly everyone follows at the end of the day and that has little explicit justification.
The note is below the line.
-------------------------
I anticipate some on the vegan internet accusing Cory Booker supporters of adopting an offensive animals first view and privileging animals over humans who benefit from the policies of, say, Bernie Sanders. In ordinary life circumstances, fighting multiple oppressions poses no conflict–it likely helps. I think that's still the case with Cory Booker–he's the strongest candidate on animals and the strongest, or tied for the strongest, on humans. For those who disagree with me on Booker's human policies, though, there IS a conflict. If Sanders is better for humans and Booker is better for animals, then we have to make a choice, and there is no way to get out of it without focusing more on one problem than another.
I’ve seen conversations on the vegan internet go like this:
Vegan 1: We have to support Cory Booker because he's vegan and supports animal rights!
Vegan 2: No, Cory Booker is a neoliberal shill. He voted to keep prescription drug prices high. All oppression is connected.
Vegan: Oh my gosh, I didn't know that! That's awful. I can't support him now.
Imagine instead this conversation:
Vegan 1: Vote for Bernie Sanders for economic justice!
Vegan 2: Bernie Sanders eats animals and supports the dairy industry.
Vegan 1: Oh well, nobody’s perfect.
I think these two conversations illustrate the different ways that even animal advocates often treat animal and human issues. We will not forsake human rights for animals, but we will often do the reverse. If we truly oppose all suffering, then we must face some tensions and contradictions and make the best choice, all things considered. And if you care about all sentient beings, that choice is Cory Booker.
My original version of the post included a section that I decided to delete. In the deleted section, I predicted that a lot of people concerned with animals would immediately dismiss the first true animal advocate running for president based on other stances, something they would never do for human issues. It's striking to me how accurate my predictions are, so I thought it was worth sharing what I removed from the post, which I think underlines a problem not only among vegans but also on the left in general: that there is a socially-enforced ranking of issues that nearly everyone follows at the end of the day and that has little explicit justification.
The note is below the line.
-------------------------
I anticipate some on the vegan internet accusing Cory Booker supporters of adopting an offensive animals first view and privileging animals over humans who benefit from the policies of, say, Bernie Sanders. In ordinary life circumstances, fighting multiple oppressions poses no conflict–it likely helps. I think that's still the case with Cory Booker–he's the strongest candidate on animals and the strongest, or tied for the strongest, on humans. For those who disagree with me on Booker's human policies, though, there IS a conflict. If Sanders is better for humans and Booker is better for animals, then we have to make a choice, and there is no way to get out of it without focusing more on one problem than another.
I’ve seen conversations on the vegan internet go like this:
Vegan 1: We have to support Cory Booker because he's vegan and supports animal rights!
Vegan 2: No, Cory Booker is a neoliberal shill. He voted to keep prescription drug prices high. All oppression is connected.
Vegan: Oh my gosh, I didn't know that! That's awful. I can't support him now.
Imagine instead this conversation:
Vegan 1: Vote for Bernie Sanders for economic justice!
Vegan 2: Bernie Sanders eats animals and supports the dairy industry.
Vegan 1: Oh well, nobody’s perfect.
I think these two conversations illustrate the different ways that even animal advocates often treat animal and human issues. We will not forsake human rights for animals, but we will often do the reverse. If we truly oppose all suffering, then we must face some tensions and contradictions and make the best choice, all things considered. And if you care about all sentient beings, that choice is Cory Booker.
I suspect one thing driving a lot of vegans' (and other liberals') intuitions against Booker and in favor of Bernie is the perception that Bernie is honest but Booker is not.
ReplyDeleteThe thought is that although it is bad for Bernie to model eating animals, he is not to blame for this—perhaps he lacks relevant knowledge (is partially ignorant about massive farmed animal suffering or how food purchases sustain it), or intentions (he intends simply to enjoy meals, not to sponsor massive farmed animal suffering). By contrast, the thought goes, Booker knowingly and intentionally has accepted big corporate money (at least prior to Feb. 2018), which will influence his decisions in favor of powerful corporate interests in a way injurious to ordinary working people.
A few questions remain, including these:
- How beholden is Booker to the interests of Wall Street, Big Pharma, etc.? Have these donations influenced his decisions problematically, or will they?
- How good is Bernie Sanders for nonhumans?
- If Booker is stuck with a 'corporate Democrat' image, will this compromise his ability to effectively advocate to make our food & agricultural system more ethical?
I think that's plausible, but I'm not convinced. Most anti-Booker vegans make explicit claims as to why they're anti-Booker, and it's usually a bad position on a specific issue or set of issues.
DeleteI really don't think he's that beholden to Wall Street or Big Pharma. One reason he "gets donations" from these industries is that most ways of counting donations include employees, and a lot of employees of both industries live in New Jersey. He's progressive on financial and health care issues (supports Medicare for All, e.g.). The interesting thing here is that I think Bernie lured him into a trap on this with a fake do-nothing amendment that he knew he wouldn't support, so in some way Bernie is the dishonest one.
I think the so-called corporate thing can only interfere with his chances in the primary. If he got in office, I don't think it would affect his policies on the food system much: the main constraint would be politics in general, which constrain much radical action in that sphere.
As an aside, I think Bernie would be good for nonhumans relative to a Republican or centrist Democrat, but I do genuinely think his laser-focus on inequality will lead to neglecting other issues.
Thanks for sharing this information with others. This is some what really very useful.
ReplyDeletespanish language in chennai
spanish language course in chennai
TOEFL Coaching in Chennai
French Classes in Chennai
pearson vue
German Classes in Chennai
french courses in chennai
french classes
Great, this article is quite awesome and I have bookmarked this page for my future reference. Keep blogging like this with the latest info.
ReplyDeleteAWS Training in Chennai
AWS course in Chennai
Cloud Computing Courses in Chennai
Cloud Computing Training in Velachery
Azure Training in Chennai
Azure Training center in Chennai
DevOps Certification in Chennai
AWS Training in Chennai
AWS course in Chennai
Thanks for posting this article it has really a good content.
ReplyDeleteSpoken English Classes in Chennai
Spoken English in Chennai
German Classes in Chennai
TOEFL Coaching in Chennai
IELTS Coaching in Chennai
spanish language in chennai
Spoken English Classes in Velachery
Spoken English Classes in Tambaram
This is really a valuable post... The info shared is helpful and valuable. Thank you for sharing.
ReplyDeleteaviation training in Chennai
air hostess academy in Chennai
Airline Courses in Chennai
Ground staff training in Chennai
Aviation Academy in Chennai
air hostess training in Chennai
airport management courses in Chennai
ground staff training in Chennai
Nice blog!! I hope you will share more info like this. I will use this for my studies and research.
ReplyDeletePHP Training Institute in Chennai
Best PHP training in chennai
Ethical Hacking Course in Chennai
PHP Training in Chennai
gst classes in chennai
ui ux design course in chennai
Web Designing Course in Chennai
PHP Training in Chennai
PHP Course in Chennai
Most of the blog deliver the same content repeatedly, but your blog has shared the content in different and unique way.
ReplyDeleteSpoken English Classes in Adyar
Spoken English Classes in T-Nagar
Spoken English Classes in Porur
Spoken English Classes in Chennai
Spoken English in Chennai
Spoken English Classes in Anna Nagar
ReplyDeleteThanks for your blog.... your blog is supreme... Waiting for your upcoming blogs...
Hacking Course in Coimbatore
ethical hacking course in coimbatore
ethical hacking course in bangalore
hacking classes in bangalore
PHP Course in Madurai
Spoken English Class in Madurai
Selenium Training in Coimbatore
SEO Training in Coimbatore
Web Designing Course in Madurai
Thank you so much for providing information on this. It was very useful.
ReplyDeleteAviation Courses in Chennai
air hostess course in Chennai
airport courses in Chennai
Ground staff training in Chennai
Aviation Academy in Chennai
air hostess training in Chennai
airport management courses in Chennai
ground staff training in Chennai
Thanks for this blog. It is more impressive...
ReplyDeleteCCNA Course in Coimbatore
CCNA Course in Coimbatore With Placement
CCNA Course in Madurai
Best CCNA Institute in Madurai
Java Training in Bangalore
Python Training in Bangalore
IELTS Coaching in Madurai
IELTS Coaching in Coimbatore
Java Training in Coimbatore
I read your blog recently and its nice. Keep sharing more.
ReplyDeleteEnglish Speaking Classes in Mumbai
English Speaking Course in Mumbai
Best English Speaking Classes in Mumbai
Spoken English Classes in Mumbai
English Classes in Mumbai
German Classes in Mulund
German Language Classes in Mulund
French Classes in Mulund
French Classes in Mulund East
Thanks for sharing this great blog. That is very interesting to read and I am always searching for informative blog like this.
ReplyDeleteHtml5 Training in Chennai
Html training in chennai
Html5 Training in Adyar
DOT NET Training in Chennai
DOT NET Course in Chennai
QTP Training in Chennai
LoadRunner Training in Chennai
It looks deeply awesome article!thanks for sharing such a information with us..
ReplyDeleteIELTS Coaching in Chennai
IELTS Coaching centre in Chennai
German Classes in Chennai
Spoken English Classes in Chennai
Japanese Classes in Chennai
spanish classes in chennai
TOEFL Coaching in Chennai
IELTS Coaching in OMR
IELTS Coaching in Porur
IELTS Coaching in Adyar
Really informative blog for all people. Thanks for sharing it.
ReplyDeleteSpoken English Classes in Chennai
Spoken English in Chennai
Data Analytics Courses in Chennai
IELTS Coaching centre in Chennai
Japanese Language Classes in Chennai
TOEFL Classes in Chennai
Spoken English Classes in Tambaram
Spoken English Classes in Anna Nagar
Me2call4u is Video chat which you can random video chat and connect with anyone from the anywhere in the world with a single swipe.
ReplyDeleteThanks for sharing an informative blog keep rocking bring more details.I like the helpful info you provide in your articles. I’ll bookmark your weblog and check again here regularly. I am quite sure I will learn much new stuff right here! Good luck for the next!
ReplyDeleteWeb Designing Training Institute in Chennai | web design training class in chennai | web designing course in chennai with placement
Mobile Application Development Courses in chennai
Data Science Training in Chennai | Data Science courses in Chennai
Professional packers and movers in chennai | PDY Packers | Household Goods Shifting
Web Designing Training Institute in Chennai | Web Designing courses in Chennai
Google ads services | Google Ads Management agency
Web Designing Course in Chennai | Web Designing Training in Chennai